The Pittsburgh Steelers’ 2025 offseason has become a high-stakes chess match, with Aaron Rodgers’ prolonged free agency saga and Mike Tomlin’s growing interest in Ole Miss quarterback Jaxson Dart creating a whirlwind of drama. As the team navigates mounting frustration over Rodgers’ indecision, Tomlin’s potential pivot to drafting Dart signals a bold strategy that could redefine the franchise’s future. Here’s an in-depth breakdown of the situation, its implications, and what lies ahead.
For a closer look at how Rodgers reached this crossroads, check out From MVP to Mystery: Will the Real Aaron Rodgers Please Stand Up?
The Aaron Rodgers Standoff: A Locker Room Divided
Growing Frustration Over Uncertainty
The Steelers’ locker room is simmering with tension as players await clarity on the quarterback position. Veteran defensive leader Cam Heyward vocalized the team’s impatience, stating, “You want to be a Pittsburgh Steeler or you don’t”—a sentiment echoed by teammates frustrated by the lack of direction ahead of offseason workouts and the draft 13. With the NFL Draft (April 24–26) looming, Pittsburgh’s leadership faces mounting pressure to resolve the Rodgers saga or pivot decisively.
Contract Stalemate
Financial disagreements are central to the delay. The Steelers’ front office has refused to increase their initial one-year offer to Rodgers, who seeks a deal reflecting his value as a four-time MVP. NFL insider Dianna Russini noted, “There’s gonna be a number here that’s gonna make Aaron happy. And I just don’t know if Pittsburgh is there yet” 5. The team’s reluctance to overcommit stems from long-term concerns: Rodgers turns 42 in December, and Pittsburgh aims to draft a developmental QB regardless of his decision. Rodgers’ durability and return from his Achilles injury remain central concerns—more details on this in Is Aaron Rodgers’ Career Over?Â
Draft Anxiety
Rodgers’ hesitation may also stem from Pittsburgh’s draft strategy. The Steelers have hosted top QB prospects like Jaxson Dart and Shedeur Sanders, signaling plans to select a rookie. Mike Florio of Pro Football Talk highlighted parallels to Kirk Cousins’ situation in Atlanta, where the Falcons drafted Michael Penix Jr. despite Cousins’ $180 million deal. Rodgers, wary of being a short-term bridge, may fear a similar outcome 7.
Jaxson Dart: The Steelers’ Contingency Plan
Why Dart Fits Pittsburgh’s Vision
At 21 years old, Jaxson Dart has emerged as a prime target for the Steelers. His 2024 season at Ole Miss showcased elite potential: 4,266 passing yards, 29 touchdowns, and a 328.2 YPG average, culminating in a Gator Bowl MVP performance. Scouts rank him as the No. 3 QB prospect, ahead of Shedeur Sanders, whose stock has dipped. His rise parallels that of recent breakout draft stars like Cade Klubnik—read more on Klubnik’s journey here.Â
Feature | Jaxson Dart (2025 Projection) | Aaron Rodgers (2025 Projection) |
Age | 21 | 41 |
Contract | Rookie deal (4 years) | 1-year veteran deal |
Role | Developmental starter | Immediate starter |
Draft Capital | 1st round (No. 21) | Free agency |
Long-Term Fit | Franchise cornerstone | Stopgap solution |
Potential Upside | High | Limited, due to age |
Mobility | High | Decreased |
Arm Strength | High | Still strong, but declining |
Experience | Limited | Extensive |
Team’s Focus | Building for the future | Competing now |
The Steelers are clearly preparing for a post-Roethlisberger era-review Ben Roethlisberger’s legacy and Super Bowl wins to understand what’s at stake.
Tomlin’s Hands-On Approach
Mike Tomlin has taken a personal role in evaluating Dart, attending his top-30 visit and Ole Miss’ pro day alongside GM Omar Khan 68. The Steelers’ interest is strategic: with no second-round pick (traded for DK Metcalf), they must prioritize Dart at No. 21 or risk missing out.
The Rodgers-Dart Dynamic
Pittsburgh envisions a scenario where Rodgers mentors Dart in 2025 before passing the torch. As owner Art Rooney II stated, “We feel pretty good about [Rodgers] shaking out… [He’d] handle starting duties while [we] mold the youngster”. However, Rodgers’ reluctance to embrace this role—and the Steelers’ refusal to delay drafting a QB—has created friction.
Strategic Implications for the Steelers
Draft-Day Scenarios
- Rodgers Signs Pre-Draft: Pittsburgh drafts Dart or another QB (e.g., Jalen Milroe) to develop behind Rodgers.
- Rodgers Delays Decision: The Steelers select Dart at No. 21, risking Rodgers’ withdrawal but securing their future.
- Trade-Up for Shedeur Sanders: A costly move with the Jets (No. 7 pick) to leapfrog QB-needy teams.Shedeur Sanders is another top QB being eyed by teams-explore the debate on whether he’s the answer for Tom Brady’s Raiders.Â
Looming Deadlines
- April 24–26 (NFL Draft): Pittsburgh’s QB plans will crystallize here.
- Training Camp: Tomlin’s reported deadline for Rodgers to sign.
Roster Morale and Free Agency Fallout
Rodgers’ indecision has already impacted free agency, with potential signees hesitant to join a team lacking QB clarity. Meanwhile, Mason Rudolph—currently the Steelers’ fallback starter—has thrown just 16 TD passes since 2018, underscoring the urgency for an upgrade.
Conclusion: A Franchise at a Crossroads
The Steelers’ pursuit of Aaron Rodgers reflects a win-now mentality, but their simultaneous investment in Jaxson Dart reveals a pragmatic long-game strategy. While Rodgers’ legacy could elevate Pittsburgh’s 2025 playoff hopes, Dart represents the future of a franchise eager to avoid post-Roethlisberger mediocrity.
Tomlin and GM Omar Khan face a defining choice: appease Rodgers with concessions or commit fully to a rookie-led rebuild. Either way, the Steelers’ 2025 trajectory hinges on resolving this high-stakes quarterback quandary—and the clock is ticking.
The 2025 draft class is stacked with game-changing talent-see how Travis Hunter and others are shaping the future of the NFL.Â
Key Sources: Steelers Wire Marca SI.com Yahoo Sports The Sun